This article is part 2 of our 3-part series on Café Sustainability. To read part 1, click here.
Update July 2019: We’ve just announced a new paper cup recycling program with RecycleMe. Click here for the details, or to get involved.
As we enter plastic free July, we’ve been thinking about ways to limit our plastic usage. While our previous research identified cups as being one of the smaller net environmental footprints on the environment (0.6% of total emissions on a CO2 equivalent basis) , we are still committed to finding ways of reducing our plastic footprint.
Hold up: what’s so bad about paper cups?
There’s been a lot of noise about this in the last couple of years, but it’s still worth clarifying what we’re dealing with here. Paper cups are generally paper wrapped internally with a polymer lining (i.e. plastic). The polymer is conventionally polyethylene, however ‘biodegradable/compostable’ cups typically use a poly (lactic acid) lining. The paper is typically non-recycled paper because of hygiene standards, though double-walled cups can (legally, at least!) contain recycled paper internally.
One of the reasons the cups can’t be recycled is because the plastic layers cannot be separated from the paper layer. Even if they could, polyethylene does not biodegrade and the materials are all sent to landfill.
What about ‘Biodegradable’ Cups?
The polymer lining in ‘biodegradable’ cups is usually Polylactic Acid (PLA). Polylactic acid degrades, in compostable conditions, primarily into carbon solids, CO2 and water. However, most PLA based polymers are sent to landfill and barely degrade. When it does, a significant proportion of degradation products is methane (between 15% and 50% of the non-condensable vapor phase). An abridged lifecycle analysis for polylactic acid-type cups was done at Seven Miles using publicly available data and some from academic journal articles (specifically: this one and this one), and is shown below. We used this lifecycle to determine whether we thought it was helpful or not to use for our cup ranges.
The bottom line from the PLA life cycle analysis, even with a composting process, still generate 0.32T of CO2, and 0.16T of methane/T of compost. One could capture the methane and then combust it (which improves the environmental footprint somewhat and your recover some energy). Also, one upshot of the composting process is that some of the carbon is sequestered into the compost, which can then be returned to farmland. However, it’s certainly not emission free.
Ultimately, both conventional (PE) and biodegradable (PLA) cups are damaging to the environment, and on balance may not be any better than each other.
A better solution for disposable cups
Beyond July, we are rolling out paper cups with a new technology through Detpak’s RecycleMe program.
Detpak have integrated Smartplanet Technologies lining into paper cups. The film lining is a calcium carbonate-polyethylene mix. The lining is fully separable from paper at waste-disposal partner plants. The cup paper fibre can then be fully recycled into paper products (up to seven times). The mineral-plastic film lining is the only waste then generated that is not recyclable (this is only around 6% of the cup meaning over 90% has been diverted from landfill!).
The major benefits of this technology include:
- No major carbon emissions are produced from the cup itself (it can be 80% reused, and not ‘composted’)
- The technology to separate and recycle the cup is is part of existing recycling infrastructure with collection facilitated by Shred-X
See how the process works:
What else can we do?
Ideally, we’d eliminate all plastics in disposable items! At the very least, we are going to do our best to reduce it. So, for plastic free July, we are going to try several things in our own espresso bar:
- BYO any cup – with extra July discounts to help change habits
- Actively encourage customers to ‘dine in’ – our baristas will use their grace and tact to encourage people to sit and sip.
- Say no to a takeaway lid – trying to eliminate plastic waste
- Crazy cup competition – challenging customers to bring their most interesting ‘from home’ cup for takeaway coffee, with a reward given at the end of the month.
It’ll be interesting to see how repeat customers change their behaviours (or not) because of the above initiatives.
What do we hope comes from this?
We certainly hope to reduce our plastic usage in the long run. We also hope that the new technology being trialed in the new cups used in our espresso window will have a positive reduction in our plastic footprint.
We are also tackling other issues identified in our previous research. Our next challenge will be identifying how we can reduce energy wastage in espresso machines using smart timing technologies. Stay tuned!
Click here to find out more about our paper cup recycling partnership with RecycleMe
For more on the work of the Coffee Science & Education Centre, click here